Micheal,
You are in the right when you say this is not illegal. I searched ICC legal regulations on batting gloves and they've taken great effort explaining the size of commercial logo, etc, as typical of ICC- only thinking of the commercial interests, but nothing on fair play in terms of batting gloves.
It gives a distinct advantage and place a player who does not resort to such 3rd grade tactics at a disadvantage. Sports should always measure the skill levels(both physical & mental) of players involved, with the least assistance from outside factors. Gilly was out-of form and he was having a problem with his bat grip(thus a drop in skill) and with this outside factor he gets assistance to better his grip. How is this fair? Also imagine, if everybody start walking to the pitch with squash balls filled gloves and batting gloves looking like inflated balloons....I mean realistically do we want cricket to go down that path?
Just because it wasn't illegal, it doesn't mean its right. In terms of fair play and ethics; back in the 70's underarm bowling- though it wasn't illegal at that time, no one really exploited that loophole. As it would be a clear violation of spirit of the game and all those good things cricket stood for. Then comes a desperate Aussie skipper and he instructs his brother in thorough desperation to win a match against Kiwis. Alas! later it was made illegal. Would this also go down the same path.......
Funny thing is its always an Aussie involved in this exploitations. Now when Pandith says hell with ethics, hell with fair play, and if it is legal, then it should be used and not using it, and mere criticism of it is a sign of weakness of the Team, the fans and the overall culture.
Let me tell you, I come from a city that has no place for ethics and fair play and only the legal aspect is thought of. But is that right? Do I appreciate it after living 12 years in New York City? No obviously not.
The reason why people resort to such 3rd grade tactics and say hell with ethics is because of their own insecurities. I see that in lot of people over here. Deep down they are very insecure, so its case of , we will not win if we play fair and square, lets try to win by any means. On a broader perspective, I read somewhere how the whole Aussie psyche is mainly built on the success of their sports Teams, and this is more than any other nation. Hence win by any means and do not disgrace the nation.
Micheal, you say "ENOUGH IS ENOUGH". I agree, and lets not limit this to a few sentences here. This ought to STOP and Gilchrist has to be punished for this act. Following is a link to ICC e-mail for fans to write:
http://www.icc-cricket.com/icc/contact-us.html